Cultural heritage · 1995

What to eat near Edinburgh, Old Town and New Town

Haggis with neeps and tatties, cullen skink, cranachan and tablet: the Scottish flavours to seek out in Edinburgh, between the Firth of Forth and the Highlands.

United Kingdom

The Scottish table, from soup to the embers of whisky

Edinburgh has sat down at table with oats, the sea and pork. Between the black stones of the old town and the orderly streets of the new town, Scottish cooking presents itself without frills: thick soups for winter, smoked fish, spiced meats, sweets that taste of butter and honey. Many of the most famous dishes were not born in Edinburgh but elsewhere in Scotland, and the guides note it with a smile, because here they are all to be found. By the sea, in the port of Leith and along the Firth of Forth, the table instead looks to seafood.

  • Haggis, neeps and tatties: the national dish: a spiced mixture of sheep offal, oats, onion and fat, served with swede and mashed potatoes, traditionally with a small glass of whisky. Vegetarian versions also exist.
  • Scotch pie: a round pie with a stiff hot-water crust, filled with spiced mutton or beef, to be eaten hot with the hands.
  • Cullen skink: a creamy soup of smoked haddock, potatoes and onion. It comes from Cullen, in Moray, not from Edinburgh, but it is a classic of every menu.
  • Scotch broth: a hearty soup of barley, root vegetables, dried pulses and lamb or mutton, cooked for a long time.
  • Stovies: potatoes cooked slowly in fat with onions and often with leftover meat, a dish for home and for cold days.

From the Forth and from the smoke

The Firth of Forth brings seafood to the table, and the Scottish tradition of smoking gives flavour to the fish of the east coast.

  • Seafood of the Forth: langoustines, mussels, oysters, haddock and crab, tied to the port of Leith, where large platters of shellfish and molluscs are served.
  • Arbroath smokies: haddock tied in pairs and hot-smoked over hardwood until it turns a golden copper colour.
  • Smoked salmon: Atlantic salmon, cut into thin slices for a starter or a seafood dish.

Breakfast, oats and sweets

Oats are the base of much Scottish cooking, from breakfast to biscuits: they carry the memory of cold fields and long winters.

  • Porridge: oats cooked in water or milk, in a sweet version with syrup or fruit, or savoury; it is a mainstay of the Scottish breakfast.
  • Full Scottish breakfast: eggs, bacon, sausages, beans, tomato and mushrooms, with in addition black pudding or haggis and tattie scones, potato scones.
  • Cranachan: a dessert of whipped cream, toasted oats, honey, raspberries and whisky, traditionally tied to the harvest.
  • Shortbread: a biscuit of butter, sugar and flour, without raising agent; the triangles are called petticoat tails. It was once reserved for Christmas and Hogmanay, today it is eaten all year round.
  • Tablet: a grainy and very sweet confection, a relative of fudge, of sugar, condensed milk and butter: the good kind snaps and melts in the mouth.
  • Oatcakes: dry oat biscuits, to be eaten with cheese, soup or smoked fish.

Whisky and gin

Scotch must be distilled and matured in Scotland, in oak casks, for at least three years. Single malt whiskies come from a single distillery, blends combine malt and grain spirits, and peated malts have a taste of smoke. In Edinburgh there are guided tastings of several whiskies side by side, and in the bars gins of every colour and scent are found, from classic juniper to rhubarb and violet.

How to choose where to eat

No restaurants are named: Edinburgh has hundreds and they change constantly, above all in the festival months, when it is best to book well in advance. Fish and chips, called a fish supper, is a classic takeaway, while for a quick lunch a Scotch pie or a soup is enough. Traditional dishes frequently contain offal, oats and gluten: for allergies, ask about the ingredients. The deep-fried Mars bar, the Mars bar fried in batter, is a curiosity of north-east Scotland and not a dish of Edinburgh.

Before and after visiting Edinburgh

The historic centre is covered on foot, among steep climbs and stairways: a morning between the castle, the Royal Mile and the lanes around translates into many hours on one’s feet, so it is best to have breakfast with a good porridge and to carry water. After the visit, a tea with a little shortbread, a fish soup or a plate of haggis give warmth on windy days, while an evening at Leith, facing the sea, whets the appetite for a plate of seafood.

Organising the trip

Before sitting down to eat, it is worth arranging the rest of the visit: how to get to Edinburgh, Old Town and New Town, where to stay and the nearby airports. The whole guide is on the page Edinburgh, Old Town and New Town.

PDF guides

101 free things and how to save money

A practical guide for every trip: the 101 free things to do in Italy, Spain, Portugal, Greece and the United Kingdom, and, for 34 cities, airport connections, transport, where to sleep and eat without overspending, and free museums.

See the guides, from €3.50PDF straight after payment, readable offline too

Sources and references