Cultural heritage · 1995

Edinburgh, Old Town and New Town

United Kingdom

Two cities in one, separated by a valley

Edinburgh, capital of Scotland since the fifteenth century, has a view that is not forgotten: on one side a ridge of black rock with a castle on top and tall houses descending in a herringbone pattern, on the other, across a valley, straight streets, squares and terraces of pale stone. It is worth seeing at least once in a lifetime because it makes it possible to walk, in a few minutes, from a city that grew little by little within its walls to a city designed on paper by an architectural competition, and to understand what changes when one builds with a plan. The Old and New Towns of Edinburgh have been inscribed on the World Heritage List since 1995 as number 728, under two cultural criteria. Criterion (ii) recognises the influence of an idea across Europe: the successive planned extensions of the New Town and the high quality of its architecture set models for Scotland and beyond, and influenced urban architecture and town planning in European cities in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Criterion (iv) recognises an exceptional example illustrating important phases of history: the passage from the fortified medieval city to the planned city of the Enlightenment and then to the nineteenth-century revival of the Old Town in the Baronial style.

The site

United Kingdom. Cultural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1995.

Criteria for inscription

  • (ii) Exchange of ideas and techniques that influenced architecture, the arts, town planning or landscape
  • (iv) An outstanding example of architecture, technology or landscape illustrating a significant stage in history
Number on the List
728

A rock of volcanic origin

According to Edinburgh World Heritage, the body that looks after the site, the rock formed as a volcanic plug in the Carboniferous and glacial erosion shaped the Castle Rock and the Royal Mile, the great street that runs down the ridge. A British site devoted to World Heritage sites notes that the landscape is dominated by an extinct volcano, with peaks and ravines, and that the river Water of Leith flows through the valley. The viewpoints and the profile of the hills and buildings have inspired generations of artists and writers.

The Old Town, growing in a herringbone pattern

Around 1125 King David I granted Edinburgh the status of royal burgh, and around 1130 the chapel of St Margaret was built in the castle, probably the oldest building in the city. In 1437 Edinburgh became the principal royal residence and seat of parliament; between 1501 and 1505 James IV built the palace of Holyrood, and in 1583 the university was founded.

The Old Town follows the ridge from the castle to Holyrood with a medieval fabric of narrow lanes, called closes and wynds, and of courtyards, with tall buildings on narrow plots. Part of it are Gladstone’s Land, the Canongate Tolbooth and St Giles’ Cathedral. In 1621 building in stone was required, thatched roofs being forbidden because of the risk of fire, and after a great fire in the High Street, in 1674, it was ordered that damaged houses be rebuilt in stone. The property also includes the nineteenth-century revival in the Baronial style.

The New Town, designed by competition

In 1752 a survey of the poor conditions of the Old Town led to plans for new public buildings, to the draining of the Nor Loch, the artificial lake north of the castle, and to expansion. Between 1766 and 1767 James Craig won the competition to design the New Town, which was built between 1767 and 1890 with planned terraces and squares. Among those who worked on it were John and Robert Adam, Sir William Chambers and William Playfair. The buildings are neoclassical, in stone, with gardens integrated into the built-up area; among the monuments are the National Monument, the Nelson Monument and the Scott Monument. The New Town, says Historic Environment Scotland, is the largest and best-preserved example of Georgian planning in the United Kingdom. The two towns are linked by the North Bridge and the Mound, which cross the Waverley valley.

How large it is

The property covers about 4.5 km² and includes almost 4,500 buildings, besides ancient monuments, designed landscapes and areas of protection. About 75% of the buildings are listed, in categories A (national or international importance), B (regional) and C (local).

Integrity and authenticity

The property is coherent and easily legible, and has adapted over time. It has kept much of the city’s profile and its views, even if they have changed with the growth of a living city. Authenticity is high: buildings of all periods are carefully preserved, the streets and squares keep their layout and Edinburgh is still the administrative and cultural capital of Scotland.

How it is protected

Care of the place is shared among three bodies: the City of Edinburgh Council, Historic Environment Scotland and Edinburgh World Heritage, a charity founded in 1999 that promotes the site, distributes grants and involves communities. A coordinator oversees the implementation of the management plan, the first published in 2005 and the current one for the years 2025-2035, written with the interested parties. Scottish national rules on planning, historic buildings and ancient monuments protect the buildings, and the territory is divided into conservation areas: Old Town, New Town, Dean Village and West End. An important rule is the Council’s “skyline policy”: it controls tall buildings that might disturb the main views, and is continually reviewed.

The threats

The main danger is altering the skyline and the views with new or overly tall buildings, and it is what the skyline policy aims to prevent. Then there is tourism: according to an article published by a cultural venue in Edinburgh, visitors number more than four million a year, with strong growth in short-term lets, pressure on services at peak times and a sense of the “privatisation” of public spaces. The same article notes that new developments in the centre are often controversial, that many protected buildings require continual maintenance, committed owners and traditional trades such as stonemasons and roofers, and that many residents call for more commitment to sustainability: traffic, waste, short-term programmes. Others call for telling little-known stories, such as the role of slavery in the eighteenth-century economy and the poverty and Irish immigration of the nineteenth; of the 51 statue monuments, 48 depict white men and 3 animals.

Figures that do not add up

Figures always vary, and they are given all the same to convey an idea. For the area, Edinburgh World Heritage speaks of about 4.5 km², while a passage of the official description gives 32.88 km² (a figure converted on this page from the unit of area used by the source), an area more than seven times larger, according to a calculation of this page. The difference needs checking. Listed buildings are “about 75%” according to the official description and “more than 75%” according to Historic Environment Scotland. Visitors are “millions” for Historic Environment Scotland and “more than four million” for the article. The New Town is of 1767-1890 according to the official description and “designed in 1767” according to Historic Environment Scotland.

What the sources do not say

The sources consulted give no opening hours, prices or visiting rules and refer to the official sites. The official description does not report the date of inscription, which is derived from other sources, or a buffer zone. An official list of threats and data on the resident population are missing.

In brief

Cultural site number 728, inscribed in 1995 under criteria (ii) and (iv). About 4.5 km² and almost 4,500 buildings, the New Town built between 1767 and 1890, about 75% of the buildings listed.

Before departure

For a trip to the United Kingdom, consult the country page on Viaggiare Sicuri, the Farnesina’s service, for up-to-date advisories. For visiting conditions, it is advisable to contact the local authorities and the official UNESCO website.

Key dates

  1. 1437Edinburgh becomes the principal royal residence and seat of parliament
  2. 1767James Craig and the plan of the New Town (competition 1766-1767)
  3. 1890End of construction of the New Town
  4. 1995Inscription on the List

Map of the site

© OpenStreetMap · ODbL

Sources and references