How large it is
The property is a series of 23 components, in 11 sites, spread over 8 separate areas. Six areas are in the south-west of Japan, one is in the centre and one in the north. The Arabic, Chinese, Russian and Spanish versions of the description speak of 11 sites, the French one of 23 components. Neither the overall area nor that of the buffer zones is given; the latter are controlled by city landscape regulations, which limit the height and density of buildings.
Three phases of industrialisation
The first phase is the period of the decline of the shogunate, from the 1850s to the early 1860s: local lords experimented with ironmaking and shipbuilding with second-hand Western knowledge and traditional craft skills. Most of the attempts failed, but they marked a break with the isolation of the Edo period. From the 1860s, in the Meiji era, Western technologies were imported along with people able to use them. Between 1890 and 1910 Japan industrialised on its own, with its own skills and techniques adapted to local materials and social traditions. After 1910 many sites became large industrial complexes, some still in operation.
Furnaces, shipyards and mines
Among the oldest places, the Nirayama reverberatory furnace was built by the shogunate after Perry's arrival in 1853 and completed in 1857, and produced usable cannon. At Hagi, in Yamaguchi, a foundry of the Chōshū domain operated from 1856 and seems to have been an unsuccessful prototype. At Hashino, in Iwate, a mine and foundry of the Morioka domain had three blast furnaces at the end of the 1850s, and has been carefully preserved. The Mietsu naval dock, in Saga prefecture, launched the ship Ryōfūmaru in 1865. The Imperial Steel Works of Yawata, in Kitakyūshū, and Mitsubishi's Nagasaki shipyard have remained in operation, at least in part, to this day.
Hashima, the battleship island
The most famous place is the Hashima coal mine, an island off Nagasaki that resembles a battleship. The mine, owned by Mitsubishi, closed in 1974 and the inhabitants left; in 2001 the island passed to the town of Takashima. Some buildings have collapsed, others are close to collapse, and for one source the risk of collapse is part of the tourist appeal.
A history that divides
There is a contested chapter in the history of the sites. According to South Korea and some critics, during the Pacific War Koreans and others worked against their will: at Hashima up to 800 Koreans, from 1943 to 1945, and at least 134 deaths according to one source; at Mitsubishi in Nagasaki at least 3,400 conscripted workers, and at Mitsui's Miike mine prisoners of war were employed during the war, later convicts. At the time of inscription, in 2015, Japan undertook to make it understood that many Koreans and others were brought against their will and forced to work in harsh conditions. The World Heritage Committee, in 2021, judged the information given to visitors insufficient and asked for it to be remedied by 1 December 2022. In 2020 Japan opened in Tokyo an information centre on industrial heritage with documents and oral testimonies and, later, a space dedicated to the victims. Japan maintains that it keeps its commitments and that Korean workers did not necessarily suffer worse conditions than others; in September 2023 the Committee asked for the dialogue to continue and for a report to be submitted by December 2024.
Integrity and authenticity
The components adequately cover the attributes of the property's value, although not all are equally intact. Some are fragments or archaeological remains, but they are recognisable as authentic industrial installations, and their authenticity is supported by archaeological reports, surveys and large public and private archives. Some are in more fragile condition: Hashima is deteriorating, Miike has structures in poor condition, the workshop of the Yawata steelworks is in poor condition, although there are temporary measures, and the foreign engineer's residence at Shūseikan has been moved twice and has small urban buildings beside it that spoil its view.
How it is protected
For sites no longer in use the law for the protection of cultural properties applies, and any change requires permission from the national government. For private sites still in operation the landscape law applies, which protects them as structures of landscape importance, here too with permission for changes. For each area there is a conservation plan. The system is coordinated by the Cabinet Secretariat, with a partnership agreement signed by Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal and Miike Port Logistics. It is recommended to monitor the effectiveness of the system, train staff, advise private sites and urgently prepare an interpretation strategy showing how each site connects with the others.
The threats
The main risk is physical decay: Hashima is deteriorating and at Miike the structures are in poor condition. Other pressures concern the view of the sites, spoiled by modern buildings in some places, such as Shokasonjuku, Takashima and Shūseikan. For the foreign engineer's residence the situation could improve if the surrounding buildings were demolished and future development controlled.
Figures that do not add up
Figures always vary, and they are given here all the same to offer an idea. The sites are 23 components in the English, Japanese and French versions and 11 sites in the Arabic, Chinese, Russian and Spanish ones; the two figures are compatible because one counts the components and the other the sites, but the versions do not say so. The Korean workers at Hashima are "up to 800" for one source and "at least 800" for another.
What the sources do not say
The sources consulted give no opening hours, prices or visiting rules and refer to the official websites. The overall area and a list of the sites open to visitors are missing. The exact number of people brought to work against their will is not fixed by a single source.
In brief
Cultural site number 1484, inscribed in 2015 under criteria (ii) and (iv). Twenty-three components in 11 sites and 8 areas, three phases of industrialisation between the 1850s and 1910, Hashima closed in 1974, a chapter of history still under discussion between Japan and South Korea.
Before departure
For a trip to Japan, consult the country page on Viaggiare Sicuri, the Farnesina’s service, for up-to-date advisories. For visiting conditions, it is advisable to contact the local authorities and the official UNESCO website.
Key dates
- 1857Nirayama reverberatory furnace completed
- 1974Hashima mine closes
- 2015Inscription on the UNESCO List
- 2020Industrial heritage information centre opens in Tokyo
- 2021The Committee judges the information on forced labour insufficient