Natural heritage · 2010

Phoenix Islands Protected Area

Kiribati

An almost empty ocean, populated by sharks and seabirds

Imagine a point on the map of the Pacific halfway between Australia and Hawaii, where for hundreds of kilometres there is no one: uninhabited atolls, lagoons, submerged mountains and waters of exceptional clarity, with sharks, manta rays and turtles. This is why the Phoenix Islands deserve to be known even by those who will never set foot there: they show what an ocean looks like when humans leave it in peace, and make it possible to measure how much is lacking elsewhere. The property has been inscribed on the World Heritage List since 2010 as number 1325 and is a natural site.

Criterion (vii) rewards remarkable natural phenomena and exceptional beauty: here what counts are the remoteness, the very few signs of humans, the transparency of the water and the large concentrations of marine animals and birds. Criterion (ix) concerns ongoing ecological and evolutionary processes: nomadic, migratory and open-sea breeders find here places in which to be born, and the isolated atolls host species that live only in this part of the world. At the time of inscription it was the largest and deepest World Heritage site.

The site

Kiribati. Natural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2010.

Criteria for inscription

  • (vii) Remarkable natural phenomena or landscapes of exceptional beauty
  • (ix) Ecological and biological processes showing the evolution of ecosystems
Number on the List
1325

How large it is

The area covers about 408,250 km², largely sea. The emerged land is barely 25 km². A calculation made for this page: it is more than 16,000 times the area of the emerged land, and another source compares it to California. It represents about 11.34 per cent of Kiribati's exclusive economic zone, that is, of the sea over which the country exercises economic rights. It is the first site of Kiribati on the List.

Atolls, reefs and seamounts

The group comprises three atolls with lagoons, Orona, Nikumaroro and Kanton, five low reef islands, Manra, Rawaki, McKean, Birnie and Enderbury, and two submerged reefs, Winslow and Carondelet. Underwater the landscape changes scale: the seabed averages over 4,500 metres in depth, with a maximum of over 6,000 metres. There are at least 14 seamounts, that is, volcanoes that do not reach the surface, and coral reefs crowning eight other volcanic peaks close to the surface. This variety of depths creates different habitats, in which the wildlife of the open Pacific lives.

An intact ocean

Scientists regard it as a natural laboratory, useful for studying the ecological processes of the Pacific, sea level, the growth and age of reefs and the effects of climate change. Far from inhabited places, the marine communities have all age and size classes, something increasingly rare in the tropics. Apex predators, turtles, seabirds, giant clams (the large shells) and coconut crabs are better preserved than in many systems of inhabited islands.

The known species number about 800, including about 200 of corals, 500 of fish, 18 of marine mammals and 44 of birds. In surveys around 2000 the reefs were found to be in excellent health, with no bleaching or disease, with a live coral cover of 20-40 per cent. Five islands are important bird areas and 19 species of seabirds live on the islands. A petrel, a seabird, lives only here and is endangered. The atolls are also a stopover for migratory species, and the area is an important feeding and breeding ground for tuna.

Ships, rats and rabbits: the story of an island

Even a remote place has its scars. In 1929 the steamship Norwich City ran aground at Nikumaroro: surveys between 2000 and 2015 show that a "black reef", linked to the iron of the wreck, had spread by about 1 km to the north. As for introduced animals, Asian rats arrived on McKean around 2002, perhaps from a shipwrecked fishing boat, and nearly wiped out several seabird populations; the rabbits of Rawaki damaged the vegetation. Rats and rabbits were eliminated from McKean and Rawaki in 2008, and in 2011 a new expedition targeted Enderbury and Birnie. The islands where introduced species remain, including two species of rat and cats, are still five, according to one source.

Kanton is the only permanently inhabited island, by about 20-30 people who look after it. Around the island there is a small sustainable use zone, which allows limited activities to support those who live there.

How it is protected

The area was established in 2008 and its regulations, of the same year, set its boundaries, create a management committee and require a management plan. In practice, it is the government of Kiribati that looks after it, with work involving several ministries and external partners. The plan divides the area into zones: one part, about 3 per cent (about 12,000 km²), is completely closed to extractive activities, while another, about 12.5 per cent (about 52,000 km²), has limits on fishing. A fund, managed by an independent entity, was meant to guarantee long-term financing: the first payment was five million dollars in 2013, with the aim of reaching 25 million.

Fishing licences in Kiribati's economic zone, protected area included, are granted only to those who agree not to fish in the adjacent high seas, with observers on every vessel. According to another source, from 1 January 2015 all commercial extractive activity, tuna included, was banned altogether.

The threats

The main threat is the high value of tuna fishing, which creates strong opposition to protection. To this are added illegal fishing, in the past also shark fishing for fins, introduced species, the degradation of seamounts, possible deep-sea mining, unregulated visits and climate change. Managing such a distant area costs a great deal, and the human resources of a small island State are limited.

In November 2021 the government of Kiribati announced its intention to repeal the national law and close the protected area, claiming that it had not brought the expected economic benefits. Confidential government papers, cited by a broadcaster, estimated revenue from licences at 200 million dollars a year in the event of opening, a figure that regional sources judge to be greatly inflated, because the number of fishing days allocated to Kiribati is already fixed by a regional system. The future of the area has been contested within Kiribati itself. An unofficial source writes that the area reopened to commercial fishing in 2023: this needs to be verified.

Figures that do not add up

Figures always vary, and here too they are given all the same to offer an idea. One source defines the area as the largest designated marine protected area in the world, another as the second largest and the largest heritage site. The islands still free of introduced species are three according to one source (Rawaki, McKean, Birnie) and two according to another (McKean and Rawaki). The percentages of the closed zones (3 and 12.5 per cent) come from an older description, while a later source speaks of total closure since 2015.

What the sources do not say

Opening hours, prices and visiting rules are not reported and the sources refer to the official bodies. They do not explain how to reach Kanton or whether visitors are admitted, and they do not say what the present state of fishing within the area is, nor the extent of the buffer zone.

In brief

Natural site number 1325, inscribed in 2010 under criteria (vii) and (ix): 408,250 km² of ocean with 25 km² of emerged land, eight islands, 14 seamounts and about 800 known species. Established in 2008, its future is today uncertain.

Before departure

For a journey to Kiribati, the country's page on Viaggiare Sicuri, the service of the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, should be consulted for up-to-date advisories. For visiting conditions it is best to contact the local authorities and the official UNESCO website.

Key dates

  1. 1929the steamship Norwich City runs aground at Nikumaroro
  2. 2008establishment of the protected area and first regulations
  3. 2010inscription on the World Heritage List
  4. 2015total closure to commercial fishing, according to one source
  5. 2021the government announces its intention to close the protected area

Map of the site

© OpenStreetMap · ODbL

Sources and references