Cultural heritage · 2021

The fourteenth-century fresco cycles of Padua

Eight places to see how painting changes

The Scrovegni Chapel is the best-known way into the painted Padua of the fourteenth century. The property inscribed by UNESCO in 2021 comprises eight complexes, distributed within the historic city in four components. There are places of worship, family chapels, rooms linked to the signoria and a large public palace. The frescoes selected range from the early fourteenth century to 1397. The geography of the property makes possible a rare comparison: one can see the attempts to organise space, to narrate emotions and to give form to a patron before different audiences, over almost a century and at short walking distances.

The four components group together the Scrovegni Chapel and the church of the Eremitani, Palazzo della Ragione with the Carrara Palace, the Cathedral Baptistery and its squares, the Cittadella Antoniana with the Basilica of the Saint and the Oratory of San Giorgio, and finally the Oratory of San Michele. The distinction between complexes to visit and cartographic perimeters is useful for organising the tour. The map shows the relationship between buildings and urban spaces. The visiting calendar then has to be built on the opening times of the individual places. To read the site as a whole, it is best to choose at least two of its areas and to bear in mind how the light, distance and function of the frescoes change.

The site

. Cultural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2021.

Places within the UNESCO perimeter

  • Palazzo de la Ragione Chapel of the Cararesi Palace Cathedral Baptistery
  • Oratory of St.Michael
  • Scrovegni Chapel Church of the Eremitani
  • Basilica and Monastery of St. Anthony Oratory of St. George

Criteria for inscription

  • (ii) Exchange of ideas and techniques that influenced architecture, the arts, town planning or landscape
Number on the List
1623

Giotto and the measure of narrative at the Scrovegni

Enrico Scrovegni commissioned a chapel dedicated to Santa Maria della Carità, close to his own residence in the area of the ancient Roman arena. Giotto and his workshop decorated it between 1303 and 1305, according to the chronology presented by the Musei civici. At the base of the walls the Vices and Virtues can be seen. Higher up run episodes from the lives of Mary’s parents, of the Virgin and of Christ. The Last Judgement occupies the entrance wall. The way the stories are distributed allows the person entering to pass from the succession of episodes to the great scene seen on turning towards the exit.

In the Lamentation over the dead Christ, the slope of the ground guides the eye towards the group of people gathered around the body. The angels make the grief visible in the upper part as well. Some figures are seen from behind and make one feel how much space their bodies occupy. Looking from the floor one can start from a single gesture and follow how the painter places it beside the others. In the Kiss of Judas, a cloak almost envelops Christ and draws attention to two faces close together. The array of weapons and torches conveys the pressure of a crowd in a confined space. They are two different ways of using the distance between figures to give intensity to a story.

On the entrance wall, Enrico Scrovegni appears kneeling as he offers a model of the chapel. The scene is a testimony to the way in which the man who had paid for the cycle wished to appear. The painted gesture is seen within a programme that speaks of the destiny of people and of salvation. For the modern visitor, the relationship between the small image of the building and the real space that contains it is one of the most concrete moments of the visit. It helps to imagine how much of the choice of place, programme and expense was legible to those who frequented the chapel in the fourteenth century.

How to look when time inside is short

The Chapel is visited in groups and by reservation. The regulated procedure contributes to protecting the microclimate. Consult the Musei civici portal for terms, advance booking and ticket office contacts. When time is limited, good preparation consists in recognising before entering the three or four scenes on which one wishes to dwell. Once inside, the overall view is worth as much as the detail. It may be more effective to look at the sequence of one wall, choose two episodes and reserve the remaining time for what is seen on the way back towards the exit.

The frescoes were made with procedures that required coordinating drawing, laying of the plaster and the work of the painters. In so large a cycle, the preparation of the surfaces and the sequence of working days determined the way the scenes were distributed. The starry vault completes the route with a different rhythm, perceptible even when one enters already informed about the images on the walls. A reproduction can be asked to show a face or the detail of a garment. In the chapel the visitor’s body measures how high up the episodes are and how much distance there is between the painted frame and the point where one stops walking.

The Eremitani and the painting of the court

A few steps away is the church of Santi Filippo e Giacomo agli Eremitani. It forms part of the heritage for its fourteenth-century painting, in particular for the works of Guariento and for the painterly milieu in which his projects developed. The architecture is read at a larger scale than that of the Scrovegni and the frescoes belong to a place still used for worship. It is worth taking into account the services and the conditions of each chapel. The reconstruction that followed the war damage gives the building a further history, legible through the preserved fragments and the gaps.

The Ovetari Chapel tells of a later story, linked to the fifteenth-century work of Andrea Mantegna and other painters. The serious damage from the bombing of 1944 explains the role of the fragments in today’s visit. To follow the fourteenth-century heritage, it is useful to keep the name of Guariento in mind and to link it back to the Chapel of the Carrara Palace. Here his work belonged to the milieu of the signoria. The function of the space helps to understand the difference between a programme conceived for a church and a cycle that also performed a task of representation at a court.

The Chapel of the Reggia is linked to the complex now occupied by the Accademia Galileiana. The surviving parts of the cycle give a hint of how important the relationship between painting and architecture was to the patron. It is one of the cases in which it is worth reading the opening times carefully and, if necessary, asking in advance how to gain access. Unlike a square, some rooms require the doors to be opened for a limited public. Noting which works are in the place for which they were made and which are displayed elsewhere avoids losing the thread between the monument and the nearby museums.

Palazzo della Ragione and the sky above a civic hall

The great hall of Palazzo della Ragione gives back a different function of painting. Astrological images and human activities enter the space of a civic palace, close to the markets of the squares. The appearance of the cycle is tied to the reconstruction that followed the fire of 1420, which destroyed the earlier fourteenth-century work attributed to Giotto. Here the theme of continuity requires attention to dates. The visit shows how later generations reworked an older figurative programme, adapting it to a building that continued to serve the city.

To find one’s bearings in the hall it is worth recognising the division into bands and following just one stretch. Part of the programme relates the calendar, the astral signs and human occupations. A room of great scale demands images that can be read even while moving. After the visit, in Piazza delle Erbe or Piazza della Frutta, the concrete life of the city is found again. It is an opportunity to compare the representation of trades and working seasons with the actual use of the squares and arcades that surround the palace.

The Baptistery and the point from which Paradise is seen

In the Cathedral Baptistery, Giusto de’ Menabuoi made the dome the centre of the vision. The ranks of figures are arranged around Christ. Stepping back a few paces and looking up makes it possible to recognise how the rhythm changes between the dome and the stories on the walls. The decoration is linked to the patronage of Fina Buzzaccarini, wife of Francesco il Vecchio da Carrara. The choice of a place of worship of great prominence went together with the demands of dynastic memory. The possibility of following the programme in a compact space makes particularly visible the way Giusto organised the images for those moving inside.

The baptistery and Giotto’s chapel work well in the same itinerary precisely because they ask for different gestures. At the Scrovegni, the narrative invites one to follow scenes along extended walls. In the baptistery, the position relative to the centre changes the way the tiers of the dome are seen. Devoting a few minutes to this comparison gives back the variety of fourteenth-century language without making painting a mere succession of names. If time is short, each visit can be limited to one question: where does the story begin and how does one notice that it has reached a decisive point?

The Saint and the family chapels

In the complex of the Basilica of Sant’Antonio, works by several painters are preserved. The Oratory of San Giorgio, beside the basilica, was born as the funerary chapel of the Lupi di Soragna family. The stories painted by Altichiero da Zevio link the memory of the family to devotion and to the saints chosen for the chapel. In some scenes, figures, buildings and crowd are distributed at different depths. It is useful to look for how an architectural detail helps to recognise the place of the action and how much space the painter leaves between one group and the next. Those who visited the Scrovegni in the morning find a similar question here with solutions from a few generations later.

In the basilica, the conditions of the visit also depend on the services and on the spaces open that day. The property’s portal distinguishes the rooms and the artists. For a first day, it is best to allow a margin between basilica, oratory and other bookings. The Botanical Garden is nearby and is another UNESCO property, with its own route and ticket. Those who wish to visit both can use the map to reduce travel and keep their time for the smallest rooms, where the visit may follow a set order.

The people who had Padua painted

What brings together many of these places is the possibility of recognising the patron through a gesture, an inscription or the choice of a burial. The property’s portal also highlights commissions by women. At the Eremitani, Traversina Cortellieri entrusted Giusto de’ Menabuoi with the decoration of the chapel dedicated to her son Tebaldo. In the Baptistery, the same artist was called by Fina Buzzaccarini. Two commissions received by the same painter take on different meanings when they are set back in their places, functions and family relationships. The story of the patrons becomes legible starting from the fate of a chapel and from the relationships that supported its decoration.

The variety of the people involved also helps to understand the different ambitions of the works. Those who built a funerary chapel were thinking of services and family memory. The city magistracies gathered a wider public and needed a space able to host repeated practices. At the Carrara court what counted were access, proximity to power and forms of representation. Fourteenth-century art took into account the actual presence of these people, how much time they would spend in the places and from which points they would see the scenes.

To organise the visit around this theme, one can begin with the Scrovegni and then compare the Baptistery with San Giorgio. The three places offer clues of different kinds. At the Scrovegni the visitor can pick out a person offering a model. In the Baptistery one can observe how the cycle organises a liturgical space associated with the memory of the signoria. At San Giorgio one can recognise the narrative choices of a funerary chapel. Carrying a question about the function of the room makes even scenes far apart in subject comparable.

The Oratory of San Michele, painting at the end of the century

Towards the Specola, the Oratory of San Michele preserves the cycle by Jacopo da Verona. A plaque records the date 1397, the name of the patron Pietro di Bartolomeo de Bovi and that of the artist. It is a material testimony to be read together with the narrative scenes, in which the presence of people and gestures of daily life brings the sacred episodes closer. After meeting several times the portrait of the city powers, one can follow a more minute detail: the way a painted interior seems to continue beyond the wall that contains it.

The oratory forms a logical conclusion for a chronological itinerary. Those who reach it from the centre cross a part of Padua different from that around the Roman Arena. To plan the days it is best to consider the four groups on the map and to keep the time of the Scrovegni fixed. One day may be enough for three well-chosen stops. Two allow time for the Baptistery, the group of the Saint and San Michele, with a margin for the Eremitani. Returning from the Specola area towards the centre completes a visit made also of streets, squares and relationships of distance between buildings. It is that urban fabric that allowed painting to take on so many functions in the same century.

The boundary of the property

Inscribed property
19.96 ha
Buffer zone
530 ha

Source of the surface areas: UNESCO World Heritage Centre.

Map of the site

© OpenStreetMap · ODbL

Sources and references