Cultural heritage · 1997

Cathedral, Torre Civica and Piazza Grande, Modena

The Duomo, the tower and the square are understood together

In Modena it is best to enter Piazza Grande from one of the corners and to pause before crossing it. On one side the flank of the Duomo stretches out, on the other the portico and the staircase of the Palazzo Comunale make clear where civic life took place. The Ghirlandina is seen in full by changing position, while the sculpted façade of the cathedral requires turning the corner. In a few steps the same complex passes from the great open space to the stone thresholds on which stories are told. The square helps to read how the Modenese distributed among different buildings worship, market, public assemblies and defence.

The cathedral, the Torre Civica and Piazza Grande have been inscribed on the World Heritage List since 1997. The official perimeter has an area of 12,000 m² and also includes parts of the buildings connected with the square, among them the Palazzo Comunale and ecclesiastical structures. A surface so small makes it possible to return several times to the same points and to see a different relationship each time. From the square one reads the southern side of the church and the Porta Regia. Crossing Via Lanfranco, on the other hand, one passes between the Duomo and the tower, close to one of the entrances from which the Romanesque project can be understood starting from a sculpted figure.

The site

. Cultural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1997.

Criteria for inscription

  • (i) A masterpiece of human creative genius
  • (ii) Exchange of ideas and techniques that influenced architecture, the arts, town planning or landscape
  • (iii) An exceptional testimony to a cultural tradition or to a civilisation
  • (iv) An outstanding example of architecture, technology or landscape illustrating a significant stage in history
Number on the List
827

The building site begun in 1099

The traditional starting date is 9 June 1099. A new building was to provide a suitable place for the relics of Saint Geminianus, bishop and patron of the city. The role of the community and the clergy is also known thanks to the Relatio de innovatione ecclesiae Sancti Geminiani. The text tells of the choice of Lanfranco, the difficulties and the solemn moments of the undertaking from the point of view of those who attributed a religious meaning to the building site. The history of the church can therefore be followed through two different material sources. The masonry preserves the decisions of those who built. The chronicle says how the work was remembered by people for whom raising a new cathedral was also a public act.

To understand the construction one has to picture a city with materials available from different origins. The reuse of Roman-age stone is documented in the facing and in elements used for the sculptures. Slabs and blocks could be taken from earlier buildings, selected and adapted to the new position. Looking at the joints helps to distinguish a regular surface from the variations of the pieces. One also understands how a stone can pass from a place of unknown origin to a recognisable memory of the new building. The building site lasted as long as the time needed to find, transport, lay and carve its parts.

Lanfranco articulated the exterior through arcades, half-columns and a series of small loggias running along several sides. The repetition gives unity to the building. Each wall interprets it in relation to height, entrances and the interior parts that correspond to it. Looking at the façade, then the side entrances and finally the apses, one sees how the same organisation changes with the base on which it rests. A walk around the outside before entering helps to understand how the project was laid out for people who could arrive from the square, from the northern streets or from the Via Emilia.

Wiligelmo tells Genesis on the façade

Four large sculpted slabs present episodes of Genesis. In a figure gathered beneath an arch or in the gesture of an arm, the eye recognises a moment of the story. The arrangement proceeds in sequences. To follow it one can start from the creation of Adam and Eve and see how the sculpture gives weight to the following passages, from sin to its consequences. The bodies have positions and occupy space in ways that can be observed even when distance makes the details hard to see. The relief was made for a façade, exposed to light and to a gaze from below.

In the same place the name of Wiligelmo is recorded. The inscription on the façade attributes value to his work and recognises his public presence. The possibility of linking works so ancient to the name of a sculptor gives a concrete perspective on the building site as a place of specialised activities. Around the best-known parts the contribution of several hands can be seen. In the capitals and cornices, animals, leaves and figures adapt to blocks of different sizes. A relief that accompanies an extended story may have a composition quite different from that required by the curved part above a column.

For a comparison, one can choose a relief on the façade and then look at the Porta della Pescheria. Here the iconography includes episodes and figures of secular theme. The figures that support parts of the portal render in stone an effort that those entering can understand from the way they bend. The entrance lies near the passage between the Duomo and the tower. The location suggests the variety of people who met these images, passing from one side of the centre to the other. On the side of Piazza Grande, the Porta dei Principi and the later Porta Regia offer other ways of marking the passage between the square and the interior.

The building continues after Lanfranco

The Duomo acquires historical depth when one looks at what was built after the start of the work. The Campionese masters worked between the late twelfth century and the following centuries, with interventions that changed the façade, some entrances and the interior. The rose window and the pontile are two points to include in the visit in order to recognise the different phases. The Campionese works fall in places already defined by the earlier structure. The possibility of reading them together with the works of Lanfranco and Wiligelmo makes it possible to follow the history of architecture as a process of transformation.

Inside, aisles, supports and the raised presbytery guide movement towards the crypt area. The course of the space explains why the cult of Saint Geminianus determined the programme of the church. For those entering on a day of services, the staff’s instructions and the areas actually accessible matter. A single visit can alternate a pause in the nave, a comparison with the pontile and, when possible, the descent towards the patron’s tomb. The changes of level become part of the reading and make immediate the relationship between the common space of the church and the place that guarded the relics.

The Musei del Duomo, in the buffer area of the site, make it possible to turn attention to the works from close by. Here one can look at the original metopes, sculptures with fantastic creatures, and compare the perception of a work displayed at eye level with that gained by seeking it in the structure of the building. The museum also brings together evidence of the earlier cathedral and objects linked to worship. To follow the chronology, the most useful stop may be after the Duomo. The museum materials give back a part of the transformations that outside are only guessed at from the difference of style or position.

The Ghirlandina as bell tower and civic tower

The Ghirlandina is a point of orientation before becoming a place to visit. It is seen from several streets of the centre and adjoins the church by means of two arches. The openings change in height. On the upper floors they become more elaborate, up to the octagonal part and the spire. The upper arrangement was completed in 1319 according to the UNESCO description. To recognise the construction from close by, it is best to look first at the base and then to move a few metres so as to see the summit. The strong verticality gives back a history of several phases within a common profile.

The tower belongs to the cathedral and to the civic life of the city. The bells gave signals that spread far from the point where they were produced. From the height reached by the keepers one could observe entrances, streets and movements. The Sala dei Torresani is one of the points on the visiting route. VisitModena indicates about 200 steps to reach it. Before choosing a time, assess the climb, check the calendar and consider the space of the passages. The visit from the square remains independent and can be supplemented with reading of the museums and the historic rooms. Those who climb see with particular clarity how close the square is to the Via Emilia and how it connects with the streets of the centre.

Piazza Grande, the place of public speech

The fronts of the square respond to uses that have followed one another. From the portico of the Palazzo Comunale the square is seen as a space of crossing and pause. Near the staircase one meets the Preda Ringadora, a large block of stone associated with harangues and public uses. On the corner of the palace the small figure of the Bonissima is instead placed high up. The contrast of size invites one to observe two ways in which a historical sign enters the life of a square. One offers a surface that people can approach. The other requires raising the head and recognising a presence among the corners of the building.

The historic rooms of the Palazzo Comunale make it possible to follow other eras of civic memory. The Secchia Rapita (Stolen Bucket) recalls the legendary episode elaborated in the poem by Alessandro Tassoni. The object, the literary tale and the medieval events must be kept distinct, because together they explain how a city builds its own memory from events and stories. The Acetaia Comunale, when open to visitors, allows a passage to another form of continuity. Here time is measured by the operations repeated in the barrels and by the craft of those who preserve a production. These visits have access and opening times different from those of the tower and the cathedral.

To see the square under several conditions, it can be crossed when there is activity and revisited in a quieter period. When the surface is free, its design is read together with the façades. In busy hours one sees how shelter, seating and routes work. Piazza Grande took that name after its medieval formation. The history of the word helps to hold together the permanence of the place and the transformations in the way it was lived. The changes inside the palaces and the Duomo have run alongside the life of the square without cancelling its role as a point of reference.

To which city the restorations belong

The city seen today is also the result of conservation work. Reuse, exposure to rain and the condition of the support mean that works placed high up require care different from that given to a portal through which people pass every day. In the church, the works of the Campionese masters are seen together with the older parts, while in the museum the fragments are presented with information on their context. It is useful to bear in mind that the photograph of a sculpted detail and the detail met on the façade remain distinct experiences, each able to offer information that is harder to see in the other.

In the historic centre, the simultaneous work of civic and ecclesiastical institutions makes concrete the history that the UNESCO inscription recognises. The care of the sculptures, the opening of worship and the crossings of the square take place in a shared space. A different time for the tower, a variation in the entrance of the Duomo and an activity in the square may call for reversing the order of the stops. To read the relationships among the buildings it is enough to begin outside and then choose a closer study. The complex preserves, at a very compact scale, the signs of maintenance and those of its daily function.

A day among stone, documents and city

With half a day, one would start from the façade, walk all the way round the Duomo and devote the main entrance to the church or its museums, according to opening times and interests. The tower fits in better when the available time slot is already known. With a whole day it is best to see the crypt and to read the sculptures in the museum before moving on to the Palazzo Comunale. One can continue along Via Emilia towards the Palazzo dei Musei, or stop between the square and the market to understand the commercial structure of the centre. These stops complete the visit to the city and have their own conditions of entry.

For those using a wheelchair or wishing to reduce changes of level, the VisitModena accessibility guide points to step-free access from the Porta della Pescheria in Via Lanfranco. Check with the operators which interior routes are available on the day of the visit and what alternatives exist for enjoying the view of the tower. The square allows a first orientation even with a short route. For those travelling with children, choosing a sculpted animal on the Duomo and finding others in the museum can become a concrete route, with short stops inside and outside.

It is worth reserving the last look for the whole. After the tour, the two arches between bell tower and church, the long wall onto Piazza Grande and the staircase of the palace become the points of a route already made. The UNESCO recognition is explained precisely at that scale. The sculpted images have kept their place within a work connected with the life of the community. The tower has given the city a recognisable profile. The square has brought the work of the buildings around it into relation with that of the people who continue to cross it.

The boundary of the property

Inscribed property
1.2 ha
Buffer zone
1.1 ha

Source of the surface areas: UNESCO World Heritage Centre.

Map of the site

© OpenStreetMap · ODbL

Sources and references

Bibliography