The conquest and the work of the building sites
The reign of Edward I went through several campaigns against the Welsh princes. The death of Llywelyn ap Gruffudd in 1282 marked a turning point in the conquest. The crown then extended the network of fortifications in north-west Wales. At Conwy, Caernarfon and Harlech the great building sites opened in the same phase. Beaumaris was begun later, in 1295, after the revolt led by Madog ap Llywelyn. This sequence helps to distinguish the speed of the first construction from the length of the occupation. Gates, walls and landing places answered immediate problems, while the new administrative seats needed settlements able to last.
Among the central figures of the programme is James of St George, a master of works from the Savoyard area. The experience gained across the Channel entered a system of work that could mobilise craftsmen and supplies on several fronts. To read this aspect one has to look beyond the silhouette of the towers. The repetition of types of openings, lodgings and gates shows how solutions known from different sites could be used. What remained to be decided case by case were the position of the entrances, the difference in level to be overcome and the means of ensuring supplies.
The Edwardian documentation makes it possible to follow many phases of the works and to measure the scale of the crown’s investment. Caernarfon required work spread over decades. The great fabric of Conwy took shape in a few years. At Beaumaris part of the programme remained unfinished. The difference between these building sites makes visible the relationship between available resources, military priorities and architectural ambitions. Today’s landscape preserves the results of decisions that could change before all the walls had even reached their intended height.
Conwy, a town within the walls
Conwy castle and the town walls were built between 1283 and 1287. The castle enclosure stretches along the rocky rise at one end of the town. Two wards organise the passage from the service areas to the more private lodgings. Visiting them in succession, the role of thresholds is perceived. From the first courtyard one passes towards the part intended for residence, with protected spaces and views over a stretch of the estuary. At another scale the same principle appears in the town, where gates and towers mark out the crossing points.
From the castle’s wall-walk the link with the harbour is understood. The ground slopes down towards the water, while the town wall rises on the opposite side and returns towards the river. The walls form a circuit of about 1.3 kilometres. Recognising its course from the street helps in finding one’s bearings even when individual raised stretches are closed. From the inner streets one sees how the urban fabric continued to develop beside the enclosure. The modern crossings and the tracks, observed from above where access is permitted, make evident the work needed to make active infrastructure coexist with medieval fortification.
It is advisable to distinguish the visit to the castle from the walk on the walls. The access conditions are published separately by Cadw. In the castle the changes of level and the spiral staircases may affect the route, while the urban walk makes it possible to approach the gates and curtain walls from below. With limited time one can choose a stretch of wall and keep a pause on the riverfront. The passage from the harbour to the upper town gives back the succession of spaces that a panoramic view shows all at once.
Caernarfon, defence and residence on the Seiont
At Caernarfon the castle dominates the meeting of the river Seiont and the Menai Strait. The polygonal towers give the fortress a profile distinct from the cylindrical towers of Conwy. In the facing, horizontal bands of stone of different colour can be seen. From a distance, the repetition of the bands holds walls and towers together. Approaching the King’s Gate, on the other hand, one recognises the depth of the passage and understands how the entrance was a point to be controlled. The two scales of reading, architecture of display and defended access, are both necessary for understanding the complex.
Cadw links the appearance of the towers and of the masonry to imperial references and to the wish to represent the new power over Wales. Historical and symbolic analogies should be kept distinct from the data that can be verified on the spot. A polygonal tower changes the angles of view and the volume of the rooms. The presence of eagle statues is a sign of the care devoted to the public image of the building. Looking at these features together makes it possible to tackle the question of the political message without isolating a single ornament from the rest of the fortress.
In the courtyard one can follow the long axis of the castle and then look for the relationship with the reception spaces. In the levels of the King’s Gate now accessible, the openings show how the threshold was controlled from the town side. In the same visit it is worth completing a stretch outside the castle, along the waterfront and by the town gates. Caernarfon was conceived with castle, walls and quay linked together. The walk along the harbour helps to reconstruct this relationship more clearly than a succession of interior rooms alone.
Harlech, the height and the route from the sea
At Harlech the castle occupies a crag on the edge of a coastal plain. The entrance towards the village and the opposite slope tell of two ways of approaching the same fortification. From the village one reaches the official route leading to the castle. Looking towards the plain, by contrast, one grasps the difference in height that separated the enclosure from the traditional supply route from the sea. The coast has moved away from the rock, and the present position of the beach does not reflect the medieval one. To understand the site one has to reconstruct this difference while observing the terrain.
Harlech is organised with an inner and an outer circuit. From above one sees that between the two runs a lower space, to which guarded accesses correspond. The great eastern gatehouse too, observed both from the entrance bridge and from inside the courtyard, shows how much it mattered to concentrate functions in a threshold. The space of the passage was part of the defence, while the rooms of the gatehouse were integrated into the life of the enclosure. The system could exploit the natural position and maintain several successive lines of control.
During the revolt of Madog ap Llywelyn the link on the sea side made it possible to supply the castle while the land accesses were cut. Cadw describes the historic stairway along the rock. The visit also offers an opportunity to distinguish a historic route that can be reconstructed in the reading of the site from the paths open to the public. The views towards the coast and towards Eryri give back the strategic role of the height. A second look from the village then makes clearer how far the terrain dictated the form of the enclosure.
Beaumaris, the concentric design
Beaumaris was built on the low ground of the eastern shore of Anglesey. Here the design was able to develop an almost symmetrical plan. The moat and the lines of walls enclose the courtyard. Once the first entrance is crossed, one passes into a space where the higher circuit controls the route. Looking at the castle from the centre and then along the moat, two faces of the same layout are seen. From the inside the relationships between the towers emerge. From the outside it becomes clear how water, low defences and higher walls were arranged in depth.
The arrow loops repeated along the outer circuit show the care devoted to covering the sectors. The system once also included a landing place connected to the moat. The relationship with the sea must therefore be read together with the internal geometry. As at Harlech, water could serve for transporting supplies, but here the space for arriving from the estuary was part of the design on flat ground and took a different form from the climb along the crag.
The construction was conditioned by the availability of money and by the military commitments of the crown. The great inner towers remained lower than planned, and some entrances were left at the initial stage. To interpret the building it is useful to keep distinct the plan, which expresses the design clearly, from the elevation, which preserves the point at which the works stopped. A photograph from outside shows the low silhouette. The visit to the courtyard makes it possible to reconstruct how much space would have developed above the present height.
What to observe in the courtyards and towers
The word “castle” covers both defensive and residential spaces. A tower can be recognised from afar as part of the military profile and have inside it rooms on several levels, narrow passages and varied openings. At accessible points one can follow the holes for beam supports, the remains of staircases and the recesses for doors. These traces indicate vanished levels and help to picture an interior more articulated than the present open volume. At Conwy the organisation between wards and apartments is better read by walking the whole building. At Caernarfon the spaces where passage and display meet are worth a pause.
The comparison between Harlech and Beaumaris makes the concept of concentric defence concrete. Harlech bends the design to the conditions of the crag. Beaumaris arranges the lines of protection within a regular outline and lays out a moat on low ground. If only one castle is visited, a plan can still suggest this double reading. First identify the point of entry. Then follow the route to the central courtyard and try to recognise how many thresholds protected the main space. On returning outside, observe how the terrain conditioned the first approach and the possibility of supplying the garrison.
The fortified towns and the population of Gwynedd
A decisive part of the visit concerns the people who could live inside the new circuits. The crown’s urban foundations encouraged the settlement of colonists and organised a part of economic life under English control. The UNESCO site documents this change as well. At Conwy the castle is tied to a street plan still legible today, while at Caernarfon the walk from the enclosure to the harbour shows how a protected point of exchange was reached. These perspectives complement the history of the Welsh princes and of resistance to the conquest. On panels and maps, attention should be paid to the names of places in the two languages. The castle carries with it the name used to present the monument, the history of the conquest and the continuity of the communities living along its perimeter.
How to arrange the visits in north Wales
With a day available, Conwy offers castle, walls and harbour without requiring another transfer between the three points. Caernarfon can in turn support a visit of its own for those who wish to focus on the residence and the town. Spreading Harlech and Beaumaris over separate days helps to save time for travel, especially if public transport is used. Beaumaris requires reaching Anglesey, while Harlech lies further south on the coast. If different stops are combined, it is advisable to choose the route first and to check the actual departures with the transport operator.
Cadw publishes the information for the four castles and that for the walls of Conwy. Before setting out, check opening, access and the availability of the raised parts. Irregular stairs, exposed walkways and climbs may change the choice of route. Some parts of Caernarfon have dedicated access, while the possibilities change from one tower to another, and the evacuation conditions should be assessed with the operator when assistance or specific arrangements are needed.
Finally, pause in front of the harbour at Conwy, the Seiont at Caernarfon, the coastal plain at Harlech and the moat at Beaumaris. These points make it possible to understand the system even before reading a panel. The castle begins from the place from which it is reached. The waterways, the relief and the town walls are part of the same story and explain why the programme of Edward I produced four such different architectures.